BMW X1 vs X3: Which is better?

In the world of luxury SUVs, BMW stands out as a brand synonymous with refinement, performance, and innovative design. In the world of luxury compact SUVs, BMW stands out as a brand synonymous with refinement, performance, and innovative design. Two of its prominent contenders in this competitive arena are the BMW X1 and X3. As discerning consumers seek the perfect blend of style, utility, and driving experience, the decision between these two models becomes a pivotal choice.

In this comparison, we delve into the nuances of the BMW X1 and X3 to determine which model might better suit your preferences and lifestyle. Whether you prioritise urban agility or enhanced performance, BMW has a model tailored for you.

BMW X1 vs X3 Design

When it comes to design, BMW has consistently showcased its mastery in crafting vehicles that blend aesthetics with functionality. A prime example of this can be seen in the comparison between the BMW X1 and X3.

The BMW X1, classified as a "subcompact" SUV, features a sleek and modern design that's well-suited for urban environments. Its compact dimensions contribute to easy manoeuvrability, making it an ideal choice for city dwellers. The X1's exterior displays a confident stance with clean lines and a sporty front fascia. The well-proportioned body strikes a balance between sophistication and agility, while the elegantly contoured surfaces reflect BMW's attention to detail.

On the other hand, the BMW X3, positioned as a "compact" luxury SUV, projects a more substantial presence on the road. Its larger dimensions provide ample interior space and cargo capacity, catering to those who prioritise versatility. The X3's design language is characterised by a more muscular and robust appearance. The prominent kidney grille, sharp headlights, and sculpted body panels contribute to a more commanding aura.

While both the X1 and new X3 embody BMW's iconic kidney grille design, their proportions and stance set them apart. The X1's compactness is accentuated by its flowing lines and subtle curves, ideal for navigating tight city streets with panache. In contrast, the X3's bolder design elements convey strength and capability, suited for those who seek a more imposing road presence.

BMW X1 vs X3 Comfort & Quality

When comparing the interior comfort and quality of the BMW X1 and X3, you'll find that both models offer a premium and well-appointed cabin. However, there are distinctions worth comparing.

The interior materials in the BMW X1 are of high quality, with soft-touch surfaces, available leather upholstery, and tasteful trim options. BMW's iDrive infotainment system is intuitive and responsive, featuring a user-friendly touchscreen display and physical controls for easy access to various functions. For a compact SUV, the X1 offers a respectable amount of cargo space, making it practical for everyday use.

Although, the BMW X3, being a larger vehicle, provides a more spacious interior. In terms of interior quality, the X3 continues BMW's tradition of excellence. The cabin is appointed with premium materials, high-quality leather, and finely crafted details. The iDrive infotainment system is typically upgraded in the X3, often featuring a larger touchscreen and more advanced tech options.

BMW X1 vs X3 Boot Space & Storage Solutions

In the realm of luxury SUVs, the comparison between the BMW X1 and X3 extends beyond aesthetics to encompass practicality, particularly in terms of boot space and storage solutions. Both the BMW X1 and X3 place an emphasis on practicality and storage, catering to different needs and lifestyles.

The BMW X1, despite being classified as a "subcompact" SUV, cleverly maximises its interior space to offer a practical and functional experience. Its compact dimensions don't compromise its utility, as the latest X1 boasts a decent 540-litre boot space that can easily accommodate daily necessities, groceries, or luggage for a weekend getaway. This is an increase of around 50 litres compared to the older versions. The rear seats are flexible, allowing for split-folding to further expand the cargo area, catering to a range of hauling needs. In terms of storage compartments, the X1 doesn't disappoint, offering well-placed cubbies and pockets throughout the cabin to stow smaller items conveniently.

However, the BMW X3 ups the ante with even more generous interior dimensions and cargo capacity. With its larger frame, the X3 provides ample room for passengers and their belongings. The 550-litre boot space is bigger compared to the latest X1, making it well-suited for families, road trips, and bulkier cargo. The X3's rear seats can also be folded down to create an extensive loading area up to 1,600 litres, enhancing its practicality for transporting larger items. In terms of storage compartments, the new X3 offers a similar approach to the X1, with strategically placed pockets and compartments for enhanced organisation.

BMW X1 vs X3 Driving Experience

When comparing the BMW X1 and X3, two exceptional offerings with their own distinct characteristics, their driving experiences present unique attractions that cater to a diverse range of driving preferences.

The BMW X1 excels particularly in urban manoeuvrability and agile handling. Its compact dimensions translate into effortless navigation, positioning it as a superb companion for city driving. The X1 offers responsive and precise steering, empowering drivers to navigate through congested streets and negotiate tight corners with confidence. Its suspension strikes a harmonious balance between comfort and sportiness, ensuring a seamless ride over various road surfaces. While it may not be designed for high-performance thrills, the X1 delivers a composed and engaging driving experience ideal for daily commutes.

In contrast, the new BMW X3 places greater emphasis on performance and adaptability. Boasting a larger stature, the X3 commands a more authoritative presence on the road, with its driving dynamics tailored to those who desire both comfort and spirited driving. The range of engines available for the BMW X3 provides more power and acceleration options compared to the X1, presenting a broader spectrum of performance capabilities. Meticulous suspension and chassis tuning contribute to assured handling, whether navigating winding routes or cruising along motorways.

BMW X1 vs X3 Price

When considering the UK pricing of luxury SUVs, a direct comparison between the BMW X1 and X3 reveals variations that align with their respective features, size, and performance offerings.

The BMW X1 typically enters the UK market at a relatively more affordable price point compared to its larger counterparts. The BMW X1 price starts from around £34,000 which is about £3,000 lower than the equivalent Mercedes-Benz GLA. This pricing strategy reflects its compact dimensions and urban-centric focus. While still encompassing BMW's signature craftsmanship and features, the X1's price tag is often designed to be more accessible for a wider range of consumers.

On the other hand, the BMW X3 carries a higher price tag compared to the X1 due to its enhanced dimensions, more advanced features, and greater performance capabilities. In fact, UK pricing starts from around £47,000 which is £13,000 more expensive than the X1 model. This model caters to those willing to invest more for a more comprehensive package.

BMW X1 vs X3 Safety & Reliability

Both the BMW X1 and X3 prioritise safety through their incorporation of advanced technologies and structural integrity. The X1 offers a variety of safety features such as adaptive cruise control, automatic emergency braking, and lane departure warning, contributing to a secure driving experience. Its compact size allows for improved manoeuvrability and visibility, making it well-suited for urban driving scenarios. The BMW X3 builds upon this foundation with extra safety offerings. The larger size of the X3 makes it a favourable option for families.

In terms of reliability, BMW has established a reputation for making vehicles with reliable engineering. Both the X1 and X3 benefit from this legacy, with well-engineered drivetrains and components. BMW's promise to quality control and regular maintenance can contribute to prolonged reliability for either model. However, like any vehicles, regular servicing and adherence to maintenance schedules are essential to ensure continued dependability.

Our Verdict: BMW X1 vs BMW X3

In the ongoing debate of BMW's luxury SUV lineup, the verdict between the BMW X1 and X3 ultimately hinges on individual preferences and priorities. Each model boasts its own distinct set of attributes, catering to a diverse range of lifestyles and driving aspirations.

If you prioritise agility, ease of urban navigation, and an accessible luxury experience, the X1 is a clear contender. On the other hand, if you crave a more spacious interior, enhanced performance, and a higher level of refinement, the X3 is likely to better suit your desires.

In conclusion, the verdict between the BMW X1 and X3 is not about which is better overall, but rather which aligns more closely with your lifestyle and preferences. Both models demonstrate BMW's commitment to luxury, performance, and innovation, ensuring that whichever choice you make, you'll be driving a car that reflects your unique taste and requirements.

So, which BMW car would you prefer? To find out more about our BMW lease deals, simply contact our leasing specialists on 0161 667 5338. We are proud of our excellent team and customer satisfaction is at the core of everything we do. If you would like to find out more about vehicle leasing, please click here to read our blog or give us a call today.